I listened to an episode for the first time in months and I already had to go ahead and fast forward the first seven minutes while Mandy talked about herself and how Britney Snow is going to play her. I appreciate the good work she’s doing but man I don’t understand how more people don’t see through her.

I’m on #121 and for the last several episodes Eric has been talked over or silenced while Mandy and Liz chatter on.

Day one listener…wow has it gone downhill! A year ago I would have given 5 stars. Now it’s two angry women ranting and Eric immediately backs down. Isn’t he a lawyer? Do actual - and factual - research on school choice, the Lively case, etc. Sorry but not all men are evil…and no, I’m not a man. Liz and Mandy are such “fighters” for women - let’s hear your thoughts and opinions about trans playing in women’s sports.

COJ #117 has got to be the best, funniest, most gleeful episode yet. These “so-called” journalists 😉 have no effs left to give and I am here for it!. Embracing the pettiness is a power move, Mandy and Liz. As a former newspaper reporter and now a lawyer, I find the commentary among the three hosts insightful. Keep up the good work.

It’s been a very busy year and I’m running behind listening but wow was I incredibly disappointed listening to this podcast today. This use to be a really good podcast, with thorough research backing up the opinions shared… But now there is a rush to judgment to back up of all people, Blake Lively??? Yikes… Extremely painful listening to that conversation. Look, Blake cherry picked messages from a questionably obtained cell phone to send to NYT (which at least one of you seemed to somewhat realize), purposely removing context, and grossly misconstrued what happened on set (bc she seemingly did not realize it was caught on film & there was audio). Frankly, she’s been caught being dishonest and then there is the whole Ryan of it all. Deadpool’s nice pool? 🤮 SNL appearance joke? 🤮 All the interviews during it ends with us & the older ones where there is a blatant narcissist telling on themselves? 🤮 Especially that Forbes interview 🤮🤮🤮🤮Also, the NYT really botched this one and between the writer Megan’s big mouth & the metadata, I sincerely hope karma comes for the NYT. If nothing else how the NYT conducted themselves should be of the upmost concern here as the metadata amongst the asking for Baldoni team comments & posting the story hours before the deadline provided to Baldoni team anyway, all calls their journalistic integrity from my point of view…. And frankly, legacy or traditional media is really suffering from a lack of journalism ethics so having a heavy dose of karma served to them would be ideal. Several details missed/ referenced incorrectly… Also, it was not Baldoni showing a video of his wife’s birth, it was his business partner Jamey Heath and it wasn’t to persuade her about the birthing scene being nude but rather brought to her to form a basis of discussion regarding the emotion of the birthing scene… The problem with the position of just believing Blake is not all women tell the truth; Just look at Amber Heard. Its important to listen but wait for verification of the details which isn’t just important to get to truth of the matter but because it’s so important to serve women & men who have been abused and/or sexually harassed. While some may be quick to believe all women, that’s the WRONG approach - All of us have fathers, brothers, uncles, cousins, husbands, best friends, etc. and what if one of them was accused - would You just jump to believing the woman or would you be thorough in listening & waiting for the truth to come out. And while we are at it, its not okay for any woman to make such serious allegations and then take issue with the accused person defending themselves, as though they are just suppose to take the allegations, let it tear apart their life even if they have not just knowledge but concrete evidence that shows what was being alleged is not the truth. Wow… again, unbelievably disappointed. Hollywood is full of not great people and I will never understand why anyone looks up to any of them - Having thoroughly read all of the legal documents of both parties, I believe Justin, believe Blake is full of it, and believe that Blake, Ryan, Brandon, Jenny, Isabella, Colleen, Taylor are just the worst of the worst of Hollywood; I will never support anything they do ever again - rotten tomatoes for all of them! 🍅🤣 BTW, you can be a fan of Taylor but just remember Taylor (in concert, at appearances, in videos, etc.) is merely a persona and she’s not an innocent but she does love to play victim especially when there are gullibles out there that eat up her ‘oh so innocent, poor me’ victim act. Everyone is of course entitled to have their own opinion… Like I said, I’m just beyond disappointed.

This was good at one point. I can’t believe a lawyer puts his name on this.

Long time follower. I admire your work but need to take a break from the podcasts. Making up your mind with very early information about Lively/ Baldoni was very disappointing. I think Liz was trying to give him the benefit of the doubt. Erick came through like I better support the woman here to not get in trouble. Can’t listen anymore, maybe will come back later. Also, glad to see that other reviews mention a similar sentiment.

I think too much of the focus has become bitter and defensive and somewhat juvenile. Re Lively v Baldoni, there are at least 2 sides to every story, but to pick a side because of your love of TS is a middle school vibe. I know you’re smarter than that makes you sound. You’ve done such great work - I hope you get back to it.

Really enjoy podcast and advocacy. BUT after a deep dive into complaints and filings, I think your support and bias for Lively is wrong. I think she is manipulating the story for personal gain. If she falsely accused Baldoni it is disgraceful! Not only victimizing an innocent man, It will set back all the cases of women who have genuinely suffered. Please keep your journalist mind open.

Todays COJ was perhaps my favorite. I laughed so hard. I don’t think I have ever heard the word doofus used more in an adult conversation. 🤣The points you all have made are excellent, based in fact and I sure hope that Judge Gergle is listening. I always learn from your podcast. I could have listened to you all talk all day. Keep up your pesky work! ❤️❤️❤️

Thrilled for the beginning of Liz’s Dis Track Era

Fantastic show!!

My favorite part is when they act like they know more than any lawyer ever

I love listening to COJ and TS every week. They are doing great work at great personal risk, putting light on not just important local stories, but stories that reveal much greater social and cultural issues that extend well beyond SC and US borders. I learn so much and feel inspired and hopeful every episode. However, a bit of me gets crushed every time I hear an ad about a weight loss product or cosmetic procedure. Knowing that women disproportionately are targeted by these industries, harmed by these industries, triggered by these industries (eg recovering from ED), and more women listen to true crime, I’m certain I’m not alone. At best it feels greatly inconsistent with the ethos of the podcasts to promote products that tell women their bodies aren’t enough. Whatever LunaShark is paid for these ads it is 1000% deserved and then some. But I hope they can seek other ad partners soon. And yes, I fast forward, but I like everyone have to listen for a couple seconds before I realize I need to—and am triggered by then. I would also legitimately like to learn about products I can actually support.

This was interesting to listen to a rush to judgement. I thought you were smart enough to wait for both sides. You kind of made your own assumptions, and Eric come on, your an attorney.

Isn’t the first rule of journalism to not insert yourself into a story? Murdoch and Steven Smith, you are inserted in the story in numerous ways but the stupid Hulu show? I’ve read the rough draft of the script, it’s best suited for Hallmark channel.

No one fights for wealthy white women more than Mandy does. Her version of feminism is self serving and out of touch. Please at least stop pretending to fight for all women and then spend 95% of your time fighting for privileged white women.

One of my favorite podcasts! Love the different point of views you three bring to the table, especially Mr Bland! His legal wisdom is always spot on and educational. I could do with less of the politics, though, as it seems you can get overwhelmed with the left media messages.

Oh look!! She lost her fake southern accent (you all)!

This team has been the catalyst for the exposure of Alex Murdaugh’s and all the others’ thievery. I’ve been listening for all along . It only gets better. Now we have Cup of Justice which is so enlightening. This team really does believe in the justice. Thank you to the entire group for taking the time to keep on keeping on.

Look forward to the updates on the different cases provided by this podcast. Stay off the politics train and there is never a good reason to murder another human being.

I never knew how bad people could be until I started listening. Life is better when you know more and have insight and facts. Nasty criminals need to be taken down. Keep it up. Appreciate you all. Ty ty TY!

I couldn’t even sit and listen to this whole show because you need to go back and listen to that guys speech he wasn’t trying to make women stay at home. He was just trying to tell them that it’s OK and I just I don’t have no words for you, girl, just my opinion hope you do better next week

You prove uts not dead and there is hope in our corrupt (sometimes) judicial system. I love how this podcast brings FACTS…literal receipts. Your approach just hits in a different way. Journalism with proper fact checking, conversation between people who have different points of view at times but all points are valid and truly make the listener think. I also appreciate how the three of you listen to eachother and at times make eachother see things from a different point of view. It must be so stressful but you are changing history one good ‘ol boy at a time. (Yes I am very scared about the next 4 yrs- but we can/will do this!!!!) With an honest, moral attorney and two very talented journalists…I’m 100% invested every week. I look forward to our cups up ( mine is 4 shots of espresso) NOW I have to be patient & wait for True Sunlight. Another FAV!!! I love watching all of you GLOW up in your own unhurried & confident way. (David as well- the show would be lost without him) Please don’t stop! I’m from NY- and always wanted to retire down south. Charleston was my plan…not anymore. I don’t think I could live in a good ‘ol boys town……ever! But I will definitely visit! Keep up the amazing educational and informational work. You are shedding light on a dirty little secret a lot of Northerners don’t even know exists!

Love the show and thank you! Don’t go on Bluesky, Eric! Dorsey knew what Elon planned and Bluesky’s financial backer is Russian! Spoutible is the only option, no algorithms and trolls removed right away!

Been listening to y’all since the beginning. Super smart women and Eric (!) unapologetically callin like it is. Legend. Liz, you’re so sharp and witty, it’s wonderful. Constructive feedback if you’re open to it… I remember many episodes ago you said you didn’t like being called snarky. I was so surprised bc you seem to own the snark. I wouldn’t allow that from my kids or team at work bc it feels cheap and can devalue a message… There is an entertainment element to it. I value your knowledgeable contributions (you’re so smart) so I ignore the snark but if you were to omit that from COJ and True Sunlight, your credibility would reach new heights IMHO. Thanks everyone for all you do to hold corruption accountable!!!! The world NEEDS people like you to speak truth to power. It’s amazing what you’ve accomplished. PLEASE keep up your awesome and important work! And do yourselves a favor: Stop supporting Musk and move to Bluesky! I would follow you there 💗

If y’all are looking for an interesting pod, keep looking.

I have been a follower of all things Lunashark since the way back when, but I feel like Mandy, Eric, Liz and David just get even better as time goes on! Pesky for the WIN!

Stay off politics. You are totally one sided.

It’s was Cleveland Browns🤓

I’m truly shocked that MM was not listed in the defamation lawsuit. You are really backpedaling by stating that you didn’t go after BM for murdering SS. Please go back and listen to your own podcasts. You seldomly threw the word “allegedly” in there from the beginning. Also, how ridiculous is it to repeatedly mention the monogrammed cumberbund. Its the South! Everything is monogrammed! The trivial dribble you two come up with sounds like a bunch of high schoolers! This podcast was so good in the beginning. The drug smuggling background (jellyfish), for example, was fascinating! I realize some of these comments may be referencing COJ but both podcasts are repetitive. I thought y’all were going to highlight the Tucker Hipps case.

Get rid of Eric Bland and this would be a 5 star show for sure. Just lost all respect for that Eric guy recently, unfortunately can’t listen to your podcast anymore with him on. Hope you guys move on from that guy, you deserve better, a real leader.

I just got dumber listening to this podcast. How are Mandy and Liz middle-aged women with such little life experience? Their lack of basic knowledge usually gained from living life is astounding. I can’t listen to this drivel. It literally drains IQ points.

Your show vs mainstream is like eating high quality real food vs the the nutritional nothingness of fast food. Don’t ever stop!

🛎️

I love waking up on Tuesdays knowing there’s a new COJ episode to listen to. I enjoy all of them but live it when the 3 are all together. I’ve listened since the beginning of MMP and the way they have grown professionally has been impressive. It’s like a friendly group you look forward to getting together with. Keep up the good work and see you next Tuesday!

Why don’t yall go after someone that can actually do damage to this state. Such as the AG, he is going after legal fundraisers (Act Blue) and attacking abortion rights. Murdaugh will never get out of prison.

How does someone get through high school, let alone college and a degree in journalism, and say things like, “Liz and I’s friendship…?” I’s opinion is she needs to consult a grammarian.

Hard to believe these are professional journalists.

Mandy, please stop with the bad habit of “blah,blah,blah…” as a thought filler.

Love how you all decided to stay pesky!!!!! I agree I believe some whistleblower is going to come forward and there will be a movie instead of the wolf of Wall Street. It will be the Murdoch Wolf of law. Keep up the amazing work. I love to listen, I was a premium member a while ago went through a little bit of hard tight money times, but I’ll be going on to become a premium member again tonight you guys are amazing🩷

At the beginning, this was really good, but they started getting very critical of anyone who disagrees with them even has nothing to do with their original podcast, and they seem to never talk about women a color or anyone other than white people, that’s really upsetting and sad. It’s also really annoying that they’re talking about celebrities and places they traveled to, and they have a lot of ads about body modifications. not in alignment with what I thought they were gonna be doing and disappointing.

Every week, I eagerly look forward to COJ and True Sunlight to show up in my feed! Thank you for keeping up the good fight. You are informed, factual, diplomatic, classy, and kind. Anyone who says otherwise is a doofus and/or a criminal. ;)

I could not tell if your 7/26/24 podcast froze with ad free subscription 23 minutes from end, or if it required a subscription to listen to the end.

Not the same. I haven’t been able to get through the last few episodes and I was a huge fan. Not sure what happened but it’s giving me misandry. Eric is fantastic and why I attempt to listen. I also have issues with vocal fry and for some reason it’s been tough to listen lately. Sorry guys.

Mande complained for months about Harpootlian and whatever it was he said about her….but they talk even worse about him and Murdaugh. Or is it ok for them to say it because they’re women? It’s hard to listen to with all there little rants and fake mad voice. If it wasn’t for Eric Bland, it wouldn’t even be worth listening to. ****Update**** It’s still terrible. Possibly even worse now.

Unsubscribed. Endless Taylor Swift worship. I wanted to be here for justice for Stephen Smith, I’ll check back when there is an update. But I am done. Some of us don’t care about celebrities or how much you worship them. Jesus Mary and Joseph! If you like this pop star so much … just start a podcast about her! I’m not listening to a justice podcast for that!

Is the clerk of court in myrtle beach related to Heather Elvis? Just wondering because it’s in the same area

I listen to this podcast to fall asleep at night. I stopped listening to true crime because it was giving me nightmares. I enjoy Mr. Bland’s insights into the legal world, but there’s nothing on the show that I feel I have a “need” to know. Therefore, I doze off after about 15 minutes, and don’t have to worry about trying to “rewind” the next night. I just move on and start with the next episode, although I have started skipping some now that they are talking about the Royals. What do they have to do with everyone having a “Cup of Justice”?

Powerful and informative show today! Guest brought the receipts on DV statistics and the were shocking!