I don’t review many podcasts, but this one deserves all the stars. I eagerly await each new exhibit. Waiting until they all drop and then binging them is difficult, but it helps immerse me in the story and keep track of all the twists and turns! Thanks for the great storytelling and keep them coming!

I found this podcast after listening to Solve This Murder. I AM OBSESSED! Nathan and Marcus do such a wonderful job of integrating the thrill of solving a mystery with fun and unique stories! The speed at which I am flying through the episodes is slightly embarrassing, but if you like solving murders and mysteries then I cannot recommend this podcast enough!

I found this looking for a mystery-themed podcast that had nothing to do with true crime. Each arc follows a different mystery, with the hosts taking turns writing the mysteries and playing the detective. The mysteries are usually fun to solve, the writing is well done, and the hosts seem to be having a good time (which is always a plus.) One negative is that the mysteries are never particularly challenging, so you can usually put together the pieces long before the end of each arc. However, that doesn’t stop the stories from being fun to listen to and solve.

It’s like murder mysteries crossed with DnD one shot settings! Amazing!!! These guys need more press, this has got to be a lot of work and they make it seem easy to write and play through their stories

I found this podcast from solve this murder podcast I’m an frequent listener to both shows of theirs which is escape this podcast. Found yall when I listened to all of theirs needed to fill the void and I could not be happier. Thank you guys so much for an amazing way to help me pass by the time at work. Amazing podcast all around great chemistry which is a MUST for a good podcast.

I would consider myself a murder mystery buff in the most over the top way possible, and this is truly one of if not the best podcasts ever! Marcus and Nathan are hilarious and the stories they dream up are fabulously funny and so well crafted(the meta puzzles and little garbled hints are such a nice add for the puzzler in your life). I regularly fall asleep to this podcast and my only regret is missing part of the episode! However I can of course relisten later 😊. And I love all of the theme music iterations (especially Hard Boiled- ICONIC). All in all, this is a fantastic show and please never stop writing more eps!!!! PS my name is Fiona Doran but if you’d prefer a more interesting name to murder you can use Diane/Diana Doran or Gypsy Doran (my cats, also fans ofc)

Cannot recommend this podcast enough if you like murder mystery fiction. The two hosts are clearly very passionate about the genre and are willing to write mysteries in out of the ordinary settings (sci-fi robot world, time loop, off-brand magic school) and it makes for an experience like no other.

This is a amazing podcast I have listened to every episode. It has phenomenal writers with amazing twists and turns. I love that you guys have a podcast for a hamster murder to a monster summer camp. This Is a great show and I would recommend it to everyone. P.s. I would love if you used my name for a character! Thank y’all so much for using my name and making me the deceased! 😆 I saw your merch you should make one saying, ITS CHAOS ITS PANDEMONIUM SOMEONE FLIPS A TABLE! 😆

Super creative and entertaining show! Love the world building and unexpected situations the detectives and characters find themselves in! From a missing classroom pet to monster camp to steampunk half the mystery for me is figuring out the new worlds and I can’t wait to see (hear) what happens next!

What a super podcast! I'm a long time murder mystery fan and I've been absolutely loving the murder museum. The mysteries are really incredible, the sound design and music are both fantastic, and Nathan and Marcus are both really amazing hosts! Super super enjoyable, I get excited with every new episode, and I can't wait to find out more about the larger goings-on at this mysterious museum! This show is criminally good and I highly recommend it to anyone who might be interested. If you're on the edge, absolutely give it a listen, you won't regret it! <3

Clever and turns and great hosts! My kids and I love listening to them. -the mother of the fabulous Mayor Henry Schumacher who has amazing tastes in podcasts 🤣

Awesome show, guys! Came here from Escape the Podcast a while back, and have been loving it ever since! You all have made so much progress in terms of creativity and role playing! Keep up the good work! (And yeah, you guys can use my name as a character if you want)

This podcast has good sound design, wonderful stories, and a clever premise that overall makes it a winner. Highly recommend!

Hello, I am Luka, I am a big fan of your show and I have a murder mystery as a recommendation for you to make (and please credit me, my name is Luka with a K). It should take place in a classic Clue-esch manor house in the 1920s, where the victim dies in the study that is locked and bolted. Now not only we have to find out who murdered the victim but also how they got out of a locked room. If you make it, please credit me, again I’m Luka with a K!

Fun mysteries, really lovely music and effects, clever premise and intriguing meta-mystery! Treat yourself to this podcast.

This podcast is one of the highlights of my week! Fun and interesting murder mysteries in a variety of different settings (that are all somehow connected in a meta-mystery that is starting to be unraveled!!! 🤯). The mysteries are complex enough that the answer isn’t obvious from the get-go, but enough clues are given that you can solve the mystery along with the player. Marcus and Nathan keep it fun and light while playing the mysteries and they’re also GENIUS MASTERMINDS WEAVING A WEB OF MURDER AND INTRIGUE. 5 stars. Would recommend 👍 Also, their intros and outros always give me chills. 10/10 on the music and creepy curator voice! 👌 Camille Arthur

This is my new favorite podcast! Your voices are great, the stories are cohesive. Please make more immediately. -Gina G

LOVE THIS PODCAST!!!! Everything about it is top notch. The duo has the perfect balance of serious and silly. They write amazing stories and share a great enthusiasm for the solve. This, more than any other podcast, is BEGGING to be turned into a show later. I really hope this catches on and is successful for a long time.

The absolute vibes on this podcast. I can’t recommend it enough, this is so great. Every episode I think to myself “They’ve done it again! They can’t keep getting away with this!”

I love this podcast! It’s so fun and the mysteries are so creative! I never write reviews but this podcast has impressed me so much I had to tell the world. People need to check this one out. You won’t be disappointed!

I actually listen to another poscast called “Solve this Murder”. This right here is pure gold. I love it. Give me more.

Love Love Love it! The guys dynamic is great and the murders are super fun to keep up with and try to solve. Can’t wait for the next one!

Love their dynamic! And their writing and production keeps getting better and better. Please keep it up! Btw: If u want better short mysteries, Hy Conrad has a lot on his website. And some contact info for permissions ;)

Great energy between Nathan and Marcus. They are hilarious and clever. The plot lines are original detective work is great. I love pocket Watson.